Poet. - Shop NY (Near Elmira)

Ben This place has great suits and great service. Michael is fantastically helpful and has a great intuitive sense for fit and style, and the prices are totally reasonable. I bought four suits and four shirts from him and already they are my favorite formal garments. The only things I would say to be aware of are that it is by appointment only and they do not take credit cards (Venmo, cash, or check only). Those minor inconveniences aside, I will absolutely be coming back here if I need any more suits for a wedding, work, or otherwise.

Heather M Its always good here!

Summer Robbins I always have a great experience in Windsor. My daughter loves their clothes and always finds really nice pieces for her wardrobe. Today we came in to do a little shopping for a party and college. Boy was it busy! Darrell was very helpful! He helped me find items, perfumes for myself, and my daughter. This store caters to teens and young adults. Though it was hectic Darrell moved seamlessly through the store, navigating,directing, and assisting all who needed help. From prom dresses to fitting rooms! I will definitely return! It’s quickly become one of my daughter’s favorite stores! Can’t wait to see what new items will be available this spring.

S Carreiro Reached out to the owner of this shop to ask a question. Owner refused to answer a very simple question saying he doesn’t do business over the phone. I explained I live out of town so don’t want to drive all the way to Elmira until I know a bit more about the item I was interested in. He flatly refused to answer the simplest of questions. He was incredibly rude. I advise against doing business with this person.

Kori Amanda I normally don’t take the time to write Google reviews, but my aunt and I had such a wonderful experience at this boutique that I felt it was worth sharing. From the moment we walked in, we were warmly greeted and made to feel welcome. The selection of products is not only impressive but also beautifully curated, with unique pieces you don’t typically find in other consignment shops. The store itself is inviting and well-organized, which made browsing an absolute pleasure. What truly stood out, however, was the exceptional customer service. Every staff member we interacted with was friendly, attentive, and genuinely passionate about what they do. Their professionalism and kindness created a shopping experience that felt personal and memorable. I can honestly say this is the best consignment store I’ve ever visited, and I look forward to returning in the future. Keep up the amazing work!

Luciana Pampalone A great place for shopping especially at Christmas, go during the week, less crowded.